Introduction

This page provides a comprehensive analysis of the known insider trading history of Carlton L Highsmith. Insiders are officers, directors, or significant investors in a company. It is illegal for insiders to make trades in their companies based on specific, non-public information. This does not mean it is illegal for them to make any trades in their own companies. However, they must report all trades to the SEC via a Form 4. Despite these restrictions, academic research suggests that insiders - in general - tend to outperform the market in their own companies.

Average Trade Profitability

The average trade profitability is the average return of all the open market purchases made by the insider in the last three years. To calculate this, we examine every open-market, unplanned purchase made by the insider, excluding all trades that were marked as part of a 10b5-1 trading plan. We then calculate the average performance of those trades over 3, 6, and 12 months, averaging each of those durations to generate a final performance metric for each trade. Finally, we average all of the performance metrics to calculate a performance metric for the insider. This list only includes insiders that have made at least three trades in the last two years.

If this insiders trade profitability is "N/A", then the insider either has not made any open-market purchases in the last three years, or the trades they’ve made are too recent to calculate a reliable performance metric.

Update Frequency: Daily

See the list of most profitable insider traders.

Companies with Reported Insider Positions

The SEC filings indicate Carlton L Highsmith has reported holdings or trades in the following companies:

Security Title Latest Reported Holdings
US:KEY / KeyCorp Director 37,177
US:FNFG / First Niagara Financial Group, Inc. Director 0
How to Interpret the Charts

The following charts show the stock performance of securities subsequent to each open-market, non-planned trade made by Carlton L Highsmith. Non-planned trade are trades that were not made as part of a 10b5-1 trading plan. The stock performance is charted as cumulative percent change in share price. For example, if an insider trade was made on January 1, 2019, the chart will show the daily percent change of the security to the present day. If the share price were to go from $10 to $15 during this time, the cumulative percent change in share price would be 50%. A change in price from $10 to $20 would be 100%, and a change in price of $10 to $5 would be -50%.

Ultimately, we are trying to determine how closely the insider’s trades correlate to excess returns (positive or negative) in the share price in order to see if the insider is timing their trades to profit from insider information. Consider the situation where an insider was doing this. In this situation, we would expect either (a) positive returns after purchases, or (b) negative returns after sales. In the case of (a), the PURCHASE chart would show a series of upwardly sloping curves, indicating positive returns after each purchase transaction. In the case of (b), the SALE chart would show a series of downward sloping curves, indicating negative returns after each sale transaction.

However, this alone is not enough to draw conclusions. If, for example, the share price of the company was in a non-cyclical climb over many years, then we would expect all the post-purchase plots to be upwardly sloping. Likewise, non-cyclical declines over many years would result in downward sloping post-trade plots. Neither of these charts would suggest insider trading activity.

The strongest indicator would be a situation where the share price was extremely cyclical, and there were both positive signals in the PURCHASE chart and negative plots on the SALE chart. This situation would be highly suggestive of an insider that was timing trades to their financial advantage.

Insider Trading History

This table shows the complete list of insider trades made by Carlton L Highsmith as disclosed to the Securities Exchange Commission (SEC).

File Date Tran Date Form Ticker Security Code 10b5-1 Shares Remaining Shares Percent
Change
Share
Price
Tran
Value
Remaining
Value
2025-05-14 2025-05-13 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
S - Sale -5,000 37,177 -11.85 16.60 -83,000 617,138
2025-05-14 2025-05-12 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
D - Sale to Issuer -4,312 42,178 -9.28 14.70 -63,386 620,017
2025-05-14 2025-05-12 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
M - Exercise 8,626 46,490 22.78
2024-11-07 2024-11-05 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
S - Sale -9,000 37,864 -19.20 17.14 -154,260 648,989
2024-08-20 2024-08-16 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
S - Sale -10,000 46,864 -17.59 16.21 -162,100 759,665
2024-05-15 2024-05-13 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
D - Sale to Issuer -3,287 56,864 -5.46 14.86 -48,845 844,999
2024-05-15 2024-05-13 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
M - Exercise 6,573 60,150 12.27
2024-03-12 2024-03-08 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
S - Sale -7,500 53,577 -12.28 15.10 -113,250 809,013
2023-11-22 2023-11-20 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
S - Sale -10,000 61,077 -14.07 12.28 -122,800 750,026
2023-05-23 2023-05-19 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
D - Sale to Issuer -6,938 71,077 -8.89 10.67 -74,028 758,392
2023-05-23 2023-05-19 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
M - Exercise 13,876 78,015 21.63
2022-09-16 2022-09-14 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
S - Sale -5,200 64,139 -7.50 17.59 -91,468 1,128,205
2022-05-24 2022-05-23 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Deferred Shares
M - Exercise -8,928 26,319 -25.33
2022-05-24 2022-05-23 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
D - Sale to Issuer -4,463 69,339 -6.05 19.81 -88,412 1,373,606
2022-05-24 2022-05-23 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
M - Exercise 8,928 73,802 13.76
2022-05-16 2022-05-12 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Deferred Shares
A - Award 7,285 35,247 26.05
2022-03-09 2022-03-07 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
S - Sale -5,362 64,874 -7.63 22.86 -122,575 1,483,020
2021-05-17 2021-05-13 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Deferred Shares
A - Award 5,654 27,032 26.45
2021-05-12 2021-05-10 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Deferred Shares
M - Exercise 0 21,378 0.00
2021-05-12 2021-05-10 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
D - Sale to Issuer -3,361 70,236 -4.57 20.94 -70,379 1,470,742
2021-05-12 2021-05-10 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
M - Exercise 6,723 73,597 10.05
2020-05-28 2020-05-26 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
P - Purchase 2,000 66,874 3.08 11.89 23,780 795,132
2020-05-26 2020-05-21 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Deferred Shares
A - Award 12,138 26,759 83.02
2020-05-20 2020-05-18 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Deferred Shares
M - Exercise -7,497 14,621 -33.90
2020-05-20 2020-05-18 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
D - Sale to Issuer -3,748 64,874 -5.46 10.71 -40,141 694,801
2020-05-20 2020-05-18 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
M - Exercise 7,497 68,622 12.27
2019-10-28 2019-10-24 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Option to Buy
M - Exercise -9,515 0 -100.00
2019-10-28 2019-10-24 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
S - Sale -9,515 61,125 -13.47 18.07 -171,936 1,104,529
2019-10-28 2019-10-24 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
M - Exercise 9,515 70,640 15.57 11.38 108,281 803,883
2019-05-28 2019-05-23 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Deferred Shares
A - Award 7,869 21,176 59.13
2018-11-06 2018-11-02 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Option to Buy
M - Exercise -6,963 0 -100.00
2018-11-06 2018-11-02 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
S - Sale -6,963 61,125 -10.23 18.37 -127,910 1,122,866
2018-11-06 2018-11-02 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
M - Exercise 6,963 68,088 11.39 13.93 96,995 948,466
2018-05-14 2018-05-10 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Deferred Shares
A - Award 5,917 12,846 85.39
2017-11-06 2017-11-03 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
M - Exercise -7,600 0 -100.00
2017-11-06 2017-11-03 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
S - Sale -7,600 61,125 -11.06 18.39 -139,764 1,124,089
2017-11-06 2017-11-03 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
M - Exercise 7,600 68,725 12.43 13.06 99,256 897,548
2017-05-22 2017-05-18 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Deferred Shares
A - Award 6,787 6,787
2016-08-03 2016-08-01 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Option to Buy
A - Award 9,515 9,515
2016-08-03 2016-08-01 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Option to Buy
A - Award 6,963 6,963
2016-08-03 2016-08-01 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Option to Buy
A - Award 7,600 7,600
2016-08-03 2016-08-01 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Option to Buy
A - Award 5,909 5,909
2016-08-03 2016-08-01 4 KEY KEYCORP /NEW/
Common Shares
A - Award 61,125 61,125
2016-08-02 2016-08-01 4 FNFG FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP INC
Stock Options
D - Sale to Issuer -10,813 0 -100.00
2016-08-02 2016-08-01 4 FNFG FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP INC
Stock Options
D - Sale to Issuer -7,913 0 -100.00
2016-08-02 2016-08-01 4 FNFG FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP INC
Stock Options
D - Sale to Issuer -8,637 0 -100.00
2016-08-02 2016-08-01 4 FNFG FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP INC
Stock Options
D - Sale to Issuer -6,715 0 -100.00
2016-08-02 2016-08-01 4 FNFG FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP INC
Common Stock
D - Sale to Issuer -87,718 0 -100.00
2016-05-02 2016-05-02 4 FNFG FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP INC
Common Stock
A - Award 7,389 87,718 9.20
2015-04-30 2015-04-30 4 FNFG FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP INC
Common Stock
A - Award 8,361 80,329 11.62
2015-03-19 2015-03-19 4 FNFG FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP INC
Common Stock
A - Award 2,809 71,968 4.06
2014-11-13 2014-11-11 4 FNFG FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP INC
Common Stock
P - Purchase 15,000 69,159 27.70 7.53 112,950 520,767
2014-03-03 2014-02-27 4 FNFG FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP INC
Common Stock
A - Award 8,711 54,159 19.17
2013-02-26 2013-02-26 4 FNFG FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP INC
Common Stock
A - Award 8,145 45,448 21.83
2012-08-02 2012-07-31 4 FNFG FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP INC
Common Stock
P - Purchase 15,000 37,303 67.26 7.62 114,300 284,249
2012-04-03 2012-03-30 4 FNFG FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP INC
Common Stock
A - Award 6,687 22,303 42.82
2011-04-22 3 FNFG FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP INC
Common Stock
12,091
P
Open market or private purchase of non-derivative or derivative security
S
Open market or private sale of non-derivative or derivative security
A
Grant, award, or other acquisition of securities from the company (such as an option)
C
Conversion of derivative
D
Sale or transfer of securities back to the company
F
Payment of exercise price or tax liability using portion of securities received from the company
G
Gift of securities by or to the insider
K
Equity swaps and similar hedging transactions
M
Exercise or conversion of derivative security received from the company (such as an option)
V
A transaction voluntarily reported on Form 4
J
Other (accompanied by a footnote describing the transaction)